The empathetic ESFJ and the pragmatic ISTP make an intriguing pair. In addition to their differences, these two types share a number of traits that can help make a relationship easier and more successful. Pragmatism and strong desires to fix problems are two traits that these types have in common.
Generally, ESFJs and ISTPs have the potential to be strong and supportive partners. When these two types connect, they have the potential to build a relationship that’s based on mutual growth and teamwork. Both types have strong drives to fix problems. For ESFJs, the problems they like to fix tend to be centered on the people around them, while for ISTPs, they like to fix logical problems.
ESFJs and ISTPs are both particular about the types of people that they prefer to date. ESFJs tend to seek partners that they can authentically connect with emotionally, while ISTPs usually look for intellectual matches who are also capable of bringing them more in touch with their emotions.
Summary Chart: ESFJ and ISTP Compatibility vs. Possible Conflicts
|They can work together well||They have different social needs|
|They feel seen||They both can focus too much on small details|
|They pull each other out of their comfort zones||They have different values|
3 Reasons Why ESFJ and ISTP Are Good for Each Other
These are three of the reasons why ESFJs and ISTPs may be good for each other:
- They have the potential to work together well.
- They can feel seen when they are with each other.
- They pull each other out of their comfort zones.
ESFJs are great planners who work hard to follow through on their plans and achieve their goals. ISTPs, however, are less disciplined when it comes to planning and sticking to schedules. ESFJs and ISTPs can be good for each other because the ESFJ can help the ISTP be more reliable and finish their projects.
As for ISTPs, they can help ESFJs adapt to new or unexpected situations. Because ESFJs rely so much on planning things out ahead of time and working step-by-step to achieve goals, they can struggle whenever issues arise that they hadn’t planned or prepared for. ISTPs, though, who often work off the cuff, are more usually adept at adapting to new or unexpected situations and can help ESFJs work through these crises by encouraging them to come up with new plans and supporting them while they’re doing so.
Another reason why these two can potentially work together well, which can help them be good for each other, is because ESFJs and ISTPs are a good balance of thinking and feeling.
While ESFJs have dominant Extraverted Feeling (Fe) in the cognitive functions stacks, ISTPs have dominant Introverted Thinking (Ti). Because of these opposing dominant traits, they’re each able to bring something to their partnership together that can help them be more well-rounded and effective as a team:
ESFJs bring the Fe, so they can help ISTPs better understand how their actions impact others, possibly improving their social relationships and reputations, and ISTPs bring their Ti, which they can use to help ESFJs be more rational and think more logically.
ESFJs’ inferior function is ISTPs’ dominant function (Ti), and vice versa. By spending more time together and working together as a team, these two types can strengthen each other’s weaknesses while also being able to incorporate each of their strengths in their partnerships with each other and social interactions with others.
The second reason why these two types can be good for each other is that it’s possible that they may feel seen for the first time when in each other’s presence. There is a natural attraction that can happen between ESFJs and ISTPs, and ESFJs, with their strong Fe, may be one of the few types who are capable of seeing that while ISTPs typically aren’t warm people, they do strive to be helpful and supportive to others in their own way.
Having this trait of theirs be seen and appreciated by someone may make the ISTP feel more confident and understood. Likewise, though they are often underestimated due to their strong feeling natures, ESFJs are actually quite practical and resourceful, something ISTPs are sure to notice after spending time with their ESFJ partner(s). Being validated for their abilities beyond just how caring they are may make the ESFJ feel more self-assured and capable.
The third reason why these two types may be good for each other is that they pull each other out of their comfort zones. ESFJs push ISTPs to be more social and more aware of others’ feelings, while ISTPs encourage ESFJs to be more rational and introspective. Additionally, ESFJs push ISTPs to be more neat and organized, while ISTPs inspire ESFJs to be more relaxed or laid-back.
3 Reasons Why ESFJ and ISTP Are Not Good for Each Other
Though ESFJs and ISTPs can be good for each other, there are some reasons why they may not be good for each other as well:
- They have different social needs.
- They both overly focus on small details.
- They have conflicting values.
ESFJs, being extroverts, get energy from spending time with others. While many of them aren’t as sociable as other extroverts and often desire to shy away from crowds, they like to spend ample time with their close friends and loved ones. ISTPs, though, prefer having time to themselves as much as possible. Even when it comes to those they love most, this type needs some time alone from them.
Though ESFJs try to be understanding of others, when their feelings are hurt, this can be harder for them to do. So, when the ESFJ wants to spend time with their ISTP partner and is rejected, this can be upsetting for them even if they understand that time alone is what their partner needs.
Another reason why these two types may not be good for each other is that they are both Sensors and can get caught up in the small details to the point that they can fail to see the big picture. While this shared trait can be beneficial to them in some ways (they may be able to notice details that the other missed, which they may find to be helpful at the moment), often, it can get in their way.
For example, when furnishing their home or planning their wedding, an ESFJ and ISTP couple may argue over which color curtains to use or how the seating arrangement should be. This, of course, is assuming they are both equally invested in the task at hand and disagree on how to accomplish it.
When this isn’t the case, usually because the ISTP is indifferent about the matter at hand, then this may be less of an issue as ISTPs are adaptable and go with the flow about things they don’t really care about.
Another reason why their mutual focus on small details can make this couple bad for each other is because in times of crisis, they may both get bogged down by worry as they each may think up multiple worst-case scenarios to the smallest details.
And because both ESFJs and ISTPs have their intuition traits in the lower half of their cognitive function stacks, these two types may both find it hard to envision solutions that can help them through the crisis until they’re able to calm themselves down, which can take up too much time.
The third and arguably biggest reason why ESFJs and ISTPs may not be good for each other is because of their conflicting values. ESFJs are planners who like things organized and prefer to create and stick to schedules. ISTTPs, however, are impulsive procrastinators who work off of bursts of energy or motivation rather than detailed plans or schedules.
Additionally, while ESFJs typically prefer cleanliness and that their houses and personal spaces remain in order, ISTPs are usually messier and care less about their homes or personal spaces being organized.
Also, ESFJs value harmony in their relationships and interactions with others. They tend to avoid rocking the boat and instead choose to be indirect or passive whenever issues arise. ISTPs, though, usually do not care as much about maintaining the peace, so they have no problems being direct and telling their ESFJ partner what problems they have with them or their relationship.
This can come across as an attack on ESFJs, and what was meant to be an honest conversation about their problems between them can instead turn into an argument with the ESFJ throwing their emotions around and the ISTP likely making matters worse by hiding behind their logic and tearing the ESFJ’s feelings-based arguments apart with reason rather than meeting them in the middle with compassion.
These conflicts are likely to end with the ESFJ feeling hurt and the ISTP feeling frustrated and annoyed, and nothing may get resolved.
Lastly, because both types have a tendency to want to fix things according to their own values, since their values are usually so different, this can result in them trying to “fix” what they think is wrong with the other person. This is especially so for the ESFJ in the relationship who may feel like it is their duty to improve their ISTP partner, much to their partner’s displeasure.
Being Sensors, both ESFJs and ISTPs tend to prefer simple language, and they’d both rather talk about topics that are “real” and have practical purposes instead of topics that are abstract or hypothetical.
Where are they strong and why?
Where ESFJs and ISTPs are strong is in the fact that the ESFJ in their relationship may feel more comfortable carrying conversations in social settings that the ISTP may feel uncomfortable in.
Additionally, because they are both pragmatic, they both may enjoy sharing practical information with each other that they may think is useful for their partner.
Where do they have problems and why?
Where ESFJs and ISTPs may have problems is in their different communication styles. Being a feeling type, ESFJs tend to use more subjective language when talking and making arguments. ESFJs also can be quite passive, and they regularly try to avoid difficult conversations.
ISTPs, though, are typically more rational and direct. They don’t like to avoid a conversation just because it’s a difficult one to have because they’d rather fix whatever problem is affecting them. Additionally, because ISTPs are more rational and direct, their language can often be quite harsh and impersonal. This can feel to take for sensitive and warm-hearted ESFJs.
How might they improve communication?
There are a few ways that ESFJs and ISTPs can improve their communication.
- The ISTP should be more mindful of the ESFJ’s feelings and speak accordingly.
- The ESFJ should be more understanding of the ISTP’s communication style and remember that the ISTP is trying to hurt their feelings. That’s just how they communicate.
- The ISTP should try to listen to the ESFJ’s thoughts and feelings rather than just criticize them for their arguments not being rational.
- The ESFJ should work on being more direct rather than trying to avoid difficult discussions.
Where do they connect? Why?
ESFJs and ISTPs connect on their pragmatism and more down-to-earth approaches to life and conversations. Neither type spends too much time with their heads in the clouds, and they both tend to value things and experiences that are tangible.
ESFJ & ISTP: Values
Both ESFJs and ISTPs feel strongly about their values.
3 Things an ESFJ Values
- Helping others
3 Things an ISTP Values
- Personal space
- Intellectual stimulation
How do their values match up?
The things that ESFJs and ISTPs value are conflicting, and it can cause them problems in their relationship until they are able to find solutions to or ways around their contrasting ways of living life.
Love Language/Love Style
Both ESFJs and ISTPs have Physical Touch and Quality Time as two of their top love languages.
Ways ESFJs Show Their Love
ESFJs show their love in the following ways.
- They’re attentive.
- They’re affectionate.
- They’re supportive.
Ways ISTPs Show Their Love
ISTPs show their love in the following ways:
- They’re willing to make adjustments.
- They’re more warm and affectionate.
- They’re helpful and supportive.
ESFJ and ISTP in Bed
While sex is an emotional act for ESFJs, for ISTPs, while passionate, they tend to just focus on the physical aspect of it. ESFJs are one of the types less likely to want to experiment in bed and prefer that their bed activities are scheduled.
II. ESFJ and ISTP Couples/Marriage
How well-matched are they in a long-term romantic relationship?
ESFJ Male and ISTP Female
ESFJ male and ISTP female relationships can work, but not without a lot of adjusting and compromising by both parties.
While the ISTP female may love how loyal and emotionally intelligent ESFJ men tend to be, she may be put off by how inflexible and clingy he is. Also, while the ESFJ male may like how practical the ISTP female is, he may dislike how independent she is.
ISTP Male and ESFJ Female
ISTP male and ESFJ female relationships aren’t easy either.
The ISTP male may love how kind and supportive the ESFJ female is, but he may hate her desire to “fix” him and may feel trapped by her version of “helping” him. Likewise, the ESFJ female may appreciate the ISTP male’s pragmatism and intelligence, but she is likely to feel disappointed by how low-priority emotions are for him and how little he cares about scheduling things and following detailed plans.
III. ESFJ and ISTP Conflicts
Conflict is a key aspect of any relationship, and that continues to be the case when it comes to relationships between ESFJs and ISTPs.
Possible Areas of Conflict (and Why)
Conflict between ESFJ and ISTP couples can occur because of the following reasons:
- The ESFJ’s sensitivity
- The ISTP’s need for flexibility, freedom, and alone time
- The ESFJ’s need for organization and schedules
- The ISTP’s directness
How do they resolve conflict?
- The ESFJ should try to be more objective when communicating with the ISTP, and the ISTP should be more respectful and understanding of the ESFJ’s feelings.
- The ESFJ should give the ISTP more freedom, and the ISTP should be more reliable so that the ESFJ can trust that giving them freedom won’t result in the ISTP not following through on plans or their responsibilities.
- ISTP should try to be more organized and responsible, and the ESFJ should understand that ISTP doesn’t need schedules and order to function the way that they do and usually feel trapped by those expectations and restrictions.
- ISTP should be warmer in their communication towards the ESFJ, and the ESFJ should keep in mind that the ISTP isn’t trying to hurt or insult them; they’re just not as good at communicating with warmth or feeling.
How do they build trust?
ESFJs may feel more able to build trust with ISTPs who are reliable, supportive, and respectful of their sensitivity, and ISTPs may feel more able to build trust with ESFJs who are more logical, direct, and respectful of their need for personal space and freedom.
IV. ESFJ and ISTP Friendships
Despite their differences, ESFJs’ and ISTPs’ friendships can be long-lasting and strong. The two types are likely to grow and learn a lot from each other, and even if their friendship doesn’t last, they may feel appreciative of it anyway because of what they may learn from each other.
ESFJ vs. ISTP: Approach to Friendship
ESFJs and ISTPs may find themselves being drawn to each other for different reasons. The ESFJ may admire the ISTP’s adaptable and logical nature, while the ISTP may respect the ESFJ’s ability to read people and emotionally support others with genuine care and concern. The ESFJ will probably reach out to the ISTP for friendship first.
ESFJ & ISTP Friendship Dynamics
The friendship dynamics between ESFJs and ISTPs may go as follows: The ESFJ may act as a source of emotional support for the ISTP, and they may encourage them to be more organized and disciplined. The ESFJ is likely to feel very motivated to help the ISTP achieve any goals they may have, and they may do everything they can to support them emotionally and practically.
Likewise, the ISTP is likely to encourage the ESFJ to be more laid-back and less serious. They may also push them to be more rational and less concerned about what other people think of them. Additionally, the ISTP may try to support their ESFJ friend to achieve their desired goals by helping them in practical ways, such as by checking their work or progress and giving them solutions on how they think they can improve or do a better job.
What makes them good for each other as friends?
What makes ESFJs and ISTPs good for each other as friends is their ability to help each other grow and push each other out of their comfort zones. A lot of compromise is sure to be necessary for their friendship to work, and spending time together making adjustments can help both the ESFJ and the ISTP to become more evolved, well-rounded individuals.
Could they be close friends?
Yes, ESFJs and ISTPs can be close friends. However, it will take them both to be mature and willing to understand and respect their differences in order for their friendship to work well.
What are some areas that might cause them problems as friends?
Areas that might cause ESFJs and ISTPs problems as friends include the ESFJ’s strong desire for the order and the ISTP’s need for freedom as well as their contrasting energy levels.
The ESFJ may want to spend more time with the ISTP than the ISTP wants to spend with them due to their preference for being alone, and this can cause problems in their friendship.